Showing posts with label jobshopschedulingarticles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label jobshopschedulingarticles. Show all posts

Sunday, July 2, 2017

Reducing Job Shop Costs versus Increasing Job Shop Throughput

Reducing Job Shop Costs

  I was just reading an article on CNCReport.com titled "Never Enough Magnetic Mounts".  The author was calculating how much money you'd save if you invested in some magnetic strips to make finding tools faster and easier.  Here's an excerpt from the article:
Hourly Pay Rate = $15 ($0.25/minute) Time spent looking for a tool = 5 minutes Times per week looking for a tool = 3 With these numbers in place it costs nearly $200 a year in lost time and money simply searching for a tool ($0.25 x 5 mins x 3 times a week x 52 weeks = $195). The math doesn’t lie so lets get some part numbers: McMaster-Carr: Magnetic Mount – $20 – 6613A24 Allen Wrench Set – $15 – 5709A52 Good Scissors – $9 – 7091A16 Box Cutter – $5 – 4927A11 Screwdriver Set – $14 – 5791A51 Spending about $70 will save time and $200. Did we miss anything?
YES!  But I don't disagree with the recommendation, only the justification. To determine if an investment of $70 is worth it, I would NOT calculate the cost savings as done in this article.  Why?  Because the reality is that your going to pay your people their hourly rate regardless of how they spend their time. You won't actually get a reduction in their hourly rate. Saving time is NOT ...

reducing job shop costs.

Instead, I would estimate how much additional Throughput you'd generate due to being able to reduceTime-is-NOT-money or eliminate time wasted looking for tools.  For most job shops and machine shops Throughput is sales minus raw material, outside processes, freight, and sales commission (if any).  Throughput is similar to margin but without direct labor.

Increasing Job Shop Throughput

For example, if you could ship one more $500 job per week and the Throughput on that job is $375, then you would easily and quickly recover the $70 investment with first additional job shipped (and paid for). BUT BE CAREFUL! When you're considering how much additional Throughput you'll get from an investment you have to be REAL.  If you put these magnetic strips at a non-constraint, the additional Throughput will be ZERO or very low. However, if you speed up your constraint, you can and will be increasing job shop throughput!

Job Shop Scheduling

Making sure that you have all the tools you need is part of getting "full kit" in Velocity Scheduling System.  VSS is for highly custom job shops and machine shops.  It is a visual, manual scheduling system.  My experience is that it usually pays to have full kit before releasing a job. Learn how -- check out the "How to Get More Jobs Done Faster" webinar.  In 47 minutes I explain how and why full kit along with other things can help you increase your Throughput with the same people and resources.  This, of course, means that your profits will increase.  And isn't THAT really The Goal? Wishing you success! By Dr Lisa Lang This article is copyrighted by Science of Business, Inc. All rights reserved. Visit our Re-post guidelines.

http://www.velocityschedulingsystem.com/?p=2212

Friday, June 2, 2017

Dr Lisa and Theory of Constraints featured in Wire Forming Technology International

Dr Lisa was featured in the Fall 2011 Wire Forming Technology International magazine with an article titled: Velocity Manufacturing: Stop focusing on efficiency and focus on velocity to reduce lead and queue times, and to increase lead-time predictability, on-time deliveries, quality and cash flow. The article explains how highly custom job shops and machine shops can schedule and change their thinking using Goldratt's Theory of Constraints to get more jobs done faster with the same people and resources. You can check it out here: WFTI Fall 2011 Velocity Manufacturing Article

http://www.velocityschedulingsystem.com/?p=1308

Monday, May 29, 2017

Job Shop Scheduling Problems and Challenges

Job Shop Scheduling - High mix low volume job shops and machine shops can be quite a challenge to schedule.

  Why?  Here are just a few of the complex problems and challenges that plague the environment:Job Shop Scheduling
  • Bottlenecks or constraints in job shops can move based on the volume and type of work.
  • Work is diverse -- typically low volume high mix but a production job may be run on occasion, or prototypes will be in the mix.
  • Jobs are typically made to order, but there are some job shops that may make a stock part, in addition to, custom parts.
  • While producing new custom jobs are the norm, some job shops and machine shop will do repair work.
  • Shops may do some amount of on-site new work or on-site repairs.
  • Emergencies can be fairly common and can take a fair amount of capacity (2% to 30%) and be very disruptive.
  • For some shops, customers call and make changes (frequently) - dates, quantity, or change their order completely.
  • It's common place to have employees which are not cross trained at all or cross trained very little so the skill needed isn't always available.
  • Shop employees don not always show up for work or on they may not show up on time.
  • Set-up times can vary and some set-ups can take a substantial amount of time, while others take very little time. And, what's worse, is that both scenarios can occur in the same shop and at the same time.
  • The high mix low volume nature of custom job shops leads to a mix of jobs with all different quoted leadtimes.
  • The touch time to complete a job can also vary wildly. The same shop can have very short touch time jobs and at the same time have very long touch time jobs and everything in between.
  • Due to precision and/or tolerances, certain jobs have to run on particular machines, making scheduling a problem.
  • And if those weren't problem enough, some jobs have outside processing to be done and some don't. Some have more than one outside process to be and some have none.
  • The leadtime on necessary outside processes will vary by the process and the vendors do not always deliver when they promised.
  • Yield rates are not perfect -- they may not be 100% or quality issues can play a role depending on the precision and type of work.

And, regardless of all these problems that can occur in scheduling a job shop and often do, customers still want their job done on time.

Now you know why it's so difficult to schedule a custom job shop.  It is the nature of the beast. There is a solution -- it is called the Velocity Scheduling System. It was developed for highly custom job shops and machine shops where these problems and Murphy not only exist, but thrive. Velocity Scheduling is NOT software but a visual scheduling system. It is a manual system that includes a visual planning board, as well as, a visual scheduling board. These boards are customized for your specific situation. Given all the complex challenges discussed above, you can imagine how important it is to customize any solution for your particular environment. To learn more, check out the ebook tab and the webinar tab. The ebook provides more information on the scheduling challenges and the traditional solutions while the 47 minute webinar provides the VSS solution. Best Wishes, Dr Lisa By Dr Lisa Lang This article is copyrighted by Science of Business, Inc. Visit our Re-post guidelines.

http://www.velocityschedulingsystem.com/?p=2311

Job Shop Scheduling Software

 

Job Shop Scheduling Software | Machine Shop Scheduling Software

I'm like you.  I invested in job shop scheduling software (we used to own a job shop).  Spent hours and hours getting it setup up only to spend more time continuallyJob Shop Scheduling Software updating the schedule.  Why does it seem that the moment I print the schedule it's out of date?  And the software itself doesn't lead to an improvement, a little time savings but no real improvement.

Job Shop Scheduling Software - it's NOT working!

There's no question that there is an almost unlimited number of job shop scheduling problems and challenges.  And the scheduling modules that are available don't seem to fully address these problems. To try and solve these problems and challenges, we tend to add more DETAIL. If what we're doing now is not working, we just need to work harder.  Right? We spend more time updating the schedule.  We add more information.  We update more often.  We invest in software or add a module to our ERP systems that provides a way to collect and analyze the data. But, adding more detail is not the answer. Here's an excerpt from a job shop scheduling software article on thefabricator.com.
Sources concede that job shop scheduling is just too complex for software to do all the work. “There is always going to be a human element to the decision-making effort,” Lechleitner said. “I think any APS (Advanced Planning and Scheduling software), at its best, will probably get you about 80 percent there.” Liddell agreed. “The software can do 80 percent of the donkey work, which will let the scheduler do 20 percent of the fine-tuning. We’re not trying to create the perfect schedule. We’ve never seen it work.” “I have not seen any magical formula,” said Richard Henning, president, Henning Industrial Software, Hudson, Ohio. “You need to monitor the skills people have for specific operations, what machines people are assigned to work on. These are all complex relationships. You still need a human being to help you see the big picture.”
And those guys are job shop scheduling software vendors.  But in their defense software just can NOT take into account all the variability that job shops encounter.  And yes I know there are some algorithms you can run (and rerun and rerun) that will balance your capacity.  But again, it's a continual updating of the schedule. It really doesn't matter if you're running finite capacity scheduling, infinite capacity scheduling, foward scheduling, or backward scheduling -- it takes constant managing and updating. I'm not saying that you shouldn't invest in the an ERP package or even a APS package, just realize that if you just do what you're currently doing a little faster, it's likely that your productivity will not increase, your lead-time will not reduce, and your due date performance will not get better.  And isn't that the point?

Job Shop Scheduling Software Solution

Velocity Scheduling System (VSS) is NOT software.  It is a visual, manual scheduling system that will work with your existing ERP or no ERP.  It is designed specifically for high mix low volume custom job shops and machine shops whose constraint can move week to week or even day to day and who suffer from a number of the job shop scheduling problems and challenges. VSS is implemented during a 14 week coaching program.  Each shop is different and the system needs to be customized for your specific shop and challenges -- therefore coaching is extremely important and boxed solutions are not used.  Results are realized typically in week 5 but it depends on how fast your team takes action.  (more details and our guarantee below is a shorter summary) We need a list of your jobs including their due date, internal process time estimates, and outside process times (if any). And don't worry if your estimates are not accurate.   That's to be expected in a custom job shop-- we don't need more detail!  We're using the information to come up with a "priority release order".  So as long as they are relative to each other, the order is close enough. By visually managing the jobs that are currently in process and on your visual scheduling board -  Velocity Board, you eliminate the constant re-scheduling. And the Velocity Board is not like any scheduling board you've ever used.  The details of how it works are proprietary, but you get all the specifics in the 14 week coaching program and more importantly we customize it for YOUR custom, complex shop. A good visual scheduling system will help you to see if you have any issues.  Nothing can hide and nothing can fall through the cracks.  If a problem arises, you see it and can deal with it.  There's no rescheduling to do.  There's no one walking around with a schedule in their back pocket -- it's a visual SYSTEM. Jobs that are not yet in process are on your To Be Released Board in "priority release order" so that you can visually manage your backlog.  One thing we like to view visually on our TBR Board is the status of "full kit" on the jobs waiting for their turn to be released. Another component of Velocity Scheduling System is what we call "Detailed Planning".  But detail in this case is much much less.  This is where we come up with priority release order (this where we interface with your ERP or whatever you use) that we've already discussed and then we look to see if there are any issues with that release order.  For example, if we release in that order might we encounter a constraint?  If we release in that order are we likely to meet our due dates?  We predict when each job will start and when it will be completed. We do NOT try to predict when each job will be on each machine.  That level of detail is very likely to be wrong and cause massive re-scheduling.  A macro view of starting and finishing is much more predictable. The order we implement is shown in the graphic below.  But before we get to that we need to make sure that you shop is a good fit.  So I recommend you watch the scheduling webinar which will provide more detail on Velocity Scheduling System.  At the end of that webinar, I'll Job Shop Schedulingexplain how we can talk to determine if you shop is a good fit and what results are likely.  And if I don't think it would work in your case or your results would not be big enough -- I'll let you know. THE key measure in Velocity Scheduling System is productivity.  The goal is to get more done with the SAME resources (the definition of productivity).  And, if you ship more without increasing costs -- your lead-times reduce, your due date performance improves, and of course, you increase profits.  All with less chaos and less re-scheduling. Sincerely, "Dr Lisa" Lang P.S.  Check out the solution to job shop scheduling software --> How to Get More Jobs Done Faster Webinar! By Dr Lisa Lang This article is copyrighted by Science of Business, Inc. Visit our Re-post guidelines.

http://www.velocityschedulingsystem.com/?p=2450

Sunday, May 28, 2017

FREE Special Report for Machine Shop Owners

Click the link below to download the free special report for machine shop and job shop owners titled:  "The 9 Biggest Challenges to Scheduling YOUR Job Shop and Why Most Schedules are Dead on Arrival!" by Dr Lisa Lang.

https://www.VelocitySchedulingSystem.com/ebook/
After you read this free special report, please CLICK on "COMMENTS"above and post your comments. I would love to know if you agree or disagree and your reasons!

http://www.velocityschedulingsystem.com/site/?p=296

Conventional Wisdom vs "Off the Shelf TOC" vs Velocity Scheduling System

Here is the second FREE Special Report on scheduling for custom job shops by Dr Lisa Lang. This report takes an in-depth look at the differences between conventional scheduling wisdom, "Off the Shelf TOC" (Traditional DBR & Simplified DBR scheduling), and the Velocity Scheduling System. I think you will find it enlightening. It's something that most TOC consultants don't even understand. Please leave your comments and questions after reading it. https://www.VelocitySchedulingSystem.com/ebook2/

http://velocityschedulingsystem.wordpress.com/?p=79

Job Shop Scheduling using the Velocity Scheduling System

I was interviewed about Theory of Constraints by Gear Technology magazine. You can read that article here: Theory of Constraints article by Dr Lisa Lang.

http://velocityschedulingsystem.wordpress.com/2009/05/10/job-shop-scheduling-using-the-velocity-scheduling-system/

The biggest constraint we Theory of Constraints consultants find is … (part 2)

By Dr Lisa Lang We have worked with companies around the globe and the constraint is always the same.  It's how we think.  In particular, it's how the business owner or leader of the company thinks. Last time, in Part 1, we discussed the efficiency mind-set and how focusing on efficiency can lead you astray.  I made the case that efficiency is NOT a precursor to improved performance, but a by-product.  In this installment I want to discuss another type of wrong thinking - the allocation mind-set. You buy the same equipment as your competitors. You hire from the same labor pool. The only difference is how you think. Unfortunately, you and your competitors also think the same way. So you are left to compete in a market where, from your customers' perspective, you're all the same. So they make decisions mostly based on price. Let me explain some of the common ways our thinking goes wrong and the negative effect this wrong thinking can have on your business. The allocation mind-set is where we believe that in order to ensure we are going to make a profit, we have to allocate some portion of our overhead to "product cost". The idea is that if every product we sell absorbs some of our costs, then we will know at what point we are making money and we can better ensure that we cover all our costs. So when we calculate the "gross margin" (GM) of a product it looks something like this: Selling price:       $100 -COGS:                -$60 ------------------------------ Gross Margin:    $40 (also called Gross Profit) Where COGS (Cost of Goods Sold) typically include raw materials and the direct labor used to create the product or deliver the service.  (Some companies may allocate more than direct labor, but this is the most common allocated cost.) But if you think about it, direct labor really is NOT a variable cost, unless you pay piece rate. And this is true for both manufacturers and service providers (again unless you pay piece rate - which is very rare). You are going to pay your employees this week whether you sell something or not. It is this allocation of direct labor to COGS that is what I'm referring to as the "allocation mind-set". The amount of direct labor allocated to a product/service is usually based on annual volume assumptions and the estimated time a particular job will take. This means that the allocation of direct labor costs to a job or opportunity influences your decisions: ·        Which jobs/projects you take. ·        Which markets you go after. ·        Which customers get preferential treatment. ·        How much you charge. So far, you're probably thinking - yeah, that's what we do, what's the problem? The problem is that the allocations you do are based on a volume assumption and time estimates. Both of which we know one thing for sure about - they are wrong. The question is by how much and in which direction.  Not only will the amount you allocate be wrong, more importantly, it can lead you astray. The best way for me to demonstrate that is with an example. Let's say that you have a customer who wants to give you more business.  They are one of your best customers and in exchange for the additional business they want a volume discount.  The volume discount is reasonable and something you do all the time.  The problem is that the way they want the product delivered along with their low inventory requirements it's going to require you to do 3X as many set ups as you would normally do for that volume.  Using the allocation mind-set you would calculate the gross margin of this new business. And you would allocate the additional setup time to opportunity. Your COGS would include the cost of the additional setups. Now, let's say that the result is that the gross margin percent is slightly NEGATIVE with these additional setups. What would you do? Pass on the additional business? Take the business but give that customer lower priority and complain about that customer every time you run their job? What decision will you make with this cost allocation mind-set? Who knows since this isn't a real situation, but before you continue reading, please give it some thought. How do you generally feel about more setups or about lower margin work? If you're like most people you would probably pass on the business or try to negotiate with your customer to take more products at once so that you could reduce the number of setups you would do. And you may even find yourself saying "the cost of those setups makes this business unattractive for us". Let's challenge our thinking with Theory of Constraints and Throughput Accounting concepts.  Let's challenge the allocation mind-set.  First, how much throughput would the additional volume generate?  Throughput = Sales - Truly Variable Costs.  Truly Variable Costs (TVCs) are all the costs you pay as a result of selling one more.  Typical TVCs include raw materials, purchase parts, outside services, subcontracted services, freight, and sales commission.  The Theory of Constraints definition of TVCs do NOT include direct labor unless you pay piece rate.  So when we calculate the "throughput" (T) of a product it looks something like this: Selling price:      $100 -TVCs:                  -$20 ------------------------------ Throughput:       $80 Next, determine if you will need to increase your fixed costs (operating expenses) if you take this additional volume? Will you need to hire anyone or buy any equipment? If so, how much? Let's say we do not need to hire anyone or buy any equipment. And if this is the case, we don't currently have an internal constraint.   We most likely have a market constraint. The way we recommend you think about this decision is by comparing the change in Throughput (ΔT) versus the change in Operating Expense (ΔOE) as a result of this additional business. And if the ΔT is greater than the ΔOE, the difference goes to covering all your operating expenses and helping you make a profit. The fact is that, in most cases, a setup doesn't cost ANYTHING (or they cost a little raw material to get the machine lined out).  They do, however, take time.  But it is imperative that you differentiate between cost and time.  If additional setups would consume so much capacity that you would need to add equipment or people, then it would be reflected in the change in OE. But to deliver that offer you need to do more setups.  But because YOU understand that set-ups do not cost anything you are willing to do it.  And your competitors are not!  Which means you can make thinking differently pay off by taking market share. I'm not saying that if ΔT > ΔOE that you must take the business, but I am trying to get you to look at the real situation and understand the real bottom-line effect. Because in this example we would potentially pass on business that would add incremental Throughput and if you do have a market constraint then don't you need more business? Shouldn't you be trying to determine what you would need to offer your market to take market share instead of trying to talk your customer out of doing more setups? The allocation mind-set has you striving to reduce YOUR setups so that you can reduce YOUR costs. Notice that it's all about you. Not a good place to be if you have a market constraint. Now imagine that it's not the customer coming to ask you to increase your set-ups, but instead you created a Mafia Offer that better served your customers needs by: ·        increasing availability of the right products ·        by reducing overall inventory ·        by reducing the amount of cash they have tied up in inventory You can hear an example of such a mafia offer here: http://www.scienceofbusiness.com/free-stuff/free-videos-audios/video-player/videoid/20.aspx So if you improve your operations by eliminating the efficiency mind-set we talked about in Part 1 and then challenge your thinking about allocations to create a great Mafia Offer - what would happen to your business? How much more money could you make? The combination of our Velocity Scheduling System Coaching Program (for custom job shops) or Project Velocity System Coaching Program (for your engineering department) with our Mafia Offer Boot Camp will accomplish just that. In Part 3 we will cover the cost mind-set. If you have questions or comments on Part 2, please click on the "Leave a Comment" link at the top of this post. Wishing you Success! Dr Lisa (c)Copyright Science of Business, Inc. All rights reserved.

http://velocityschedulingsystem.wordpress.com/?p=371

Reshoring U.S. Manufacturing -- a 3 part article series

The final part in a 3 part series on reshoring has just been published. Part 1 is titled Velocity Manufacturing and is authored by Dr Lisa Lang . Part 2 is titled Total Cost of Ownership Calculation and is authored by Harry Moser. Then Part 3 was co-written by the two and is titled Reshoring Manufacturing Can Increase Your Competitiveness. June: http://www.bluetoad.com/publication/?i=70112&p=46 -- Part 1 August: http://www.bluetoad.com/publication/?i=77825&p=56 -- Part 2 October: http://www.bluetoad.com/publication/?i=82790&p=28 -- Part 3 This 3 part series was brought to you by Fastener Technology International. If you have questions or comments for Harry Moser or Dr Lisa -- please leave them below.

http://www.velocityschedulingsystem.com/?p=1177

Thursday, May 25, 2017

Drum Buffer Rope

Theory of Constraints Drum Buffer Rope

Drum Buffer Rope for Job Shops Drum Buffer Rope (DBR) was developed by Eliyahu M. Goldratt (Eli Goldratt), the father of Theory of Constraints.  His book The Goal tells a story of a plant manager applying the drum buffer rope concepts.

The drum is the constraint.

The resource that is limiting your output.  Most shops typically only have one constraint at any point in time, but the issue is that for many custom job shops and machine shops the constraint can move as the mix changes. A constraint is any resources that had demand greater than it's available capacity.  Any time lost on the constraint is output lost by the entire system.  Increasing output at the constraint, increases overall output. Improving non-constraints has no effect on overall output.  This is why measuring utilization everywhere makes no sense.  Trying to 100% utilize non-constraints just results in too much WIP and the many issue associated with that.

The buffer is measured in time.

It's the amount of work expressed in time (like days worth) prior to the constraint.  We control this amount of work with the rope. By having a buffer of work in front of the constraint, we can ensure the constraint does not run out of work.  The constraint is the only place where 100% utilization is a good thing! The buffer's job is to absorb variability.  In traditional Drum Buffer Rope there are 2 buffers - one for the constraint and a shipping buffer.  The one before the constraints is there to protect the constraint and the shipping buffer protects the due date. Simplified Drum Buffer Rope just has a shipping buffer. Drum is the same. Any buffers are divided into 3 zones - red, yellow, green.  If the buffer is red we find out why.  The buffer is sized so that it turns red about 5% of the time.  For continuous improvement we track the whys so that we can reduce or eliminate our biggest disruptions to flow.  These improvements to flow lead to less variability and needing less buffer!

The rope is how we control the release of new work.

The idea is that if the constraint sets the pace, the drum beat, for the entire operation, then we should only release work at the rate that the constraint can consume it. If we release work faster than the constraint can consume it, then WIP (work in process) piles up and bad things begin to happen.  (See Little's Law.) That's a brief Theory of Constraints summary of Drum Buffer Rope.  The real challenge is figuring out how to make it work in YOUR shop. The plant in The Goal is a machine shop.  It's not the most complex of cases, but it is a machine shop.

Theory of Constraints Goldratt

Velocity Scheduling System was developed for the tough cases:
  • For the custom job shops and machine shops that run high mix and low volume work or prototypes.
  • For the shops where the constraint or bottleneck moves based on the mix of work.
  • For the shops that may not run many jobs twice but can also have a production job to fit in with everything else.
  • For the shops that do repairs (in house or on-site) or emergency work.
  • For the shops that don't have perfect employee or vendor performance.
  • For the shops who don't have perfectly cross trained employees, but have jobs that require a particular machine.
  • For the shops that produce a wide range of custom parts or products that have a wide range of lead-times, set-up times and outside processes.
  • For the shops that may not have 100% quality performance and or yields that are less than 100%.
  • And, for the shops who have customers call and change quantities, dates or both.
If your shop is a custom job shop or machine shop, check out the Scheduling Reports and Scheduling Webinar tabs.  After you watch the webinar, we should talk to determine if your shop is a good fit. By Dr Lisa Lang

This article is copyrighted by Science of Business, Inc.

Visit our Re-post guidelines.

 

http://www.velocityschedulingsystem.com/?p=2295